There is no doubt that Pep Guardiola is considered one of the greatest coaches in modern football history, having revolutionized the philosophy of play and redefined the concept of “possession” and high pressing.

However, this season, Manchester City is experiencing a clear decline in performance and results, raising questions about the Spanish philosopher’s continued ability to inspire his team after nine consecutive years at the helm at the Etihad Stadium.

Excessive Philosophy or Lost Flexibility?

Guardiola faces many criticisms this season, mainly for over-experimenting tactically and excessively changing players’ positions, which has cost the team its stability.

New signings have not yet been fully utilized, while the defense suffers from clear gaps, and the attack lacks a consistent offensive identity, unlike previous years.

Mental Fatigue After 9 Seasons

It is noticeable that Guardiola previously relied on the principle of “short cycles,” spending only 4 seasons at Barcelona, then taking a break before his 3-season stint at Bayern Munich, followed by another break.

But with Manchester City, he broke this pattern, continuing for 9 consecutive years, which may have caused mental fatigue reflected in his tactical decisions and his players’ performance.

Imbalance Between Attack and Defense

The team, which used to dominate the pitch through precise passing and calculated movements, now shows unprecedented defensive fragility, with weak coverage on the flanks and absence of the gradual pressing that characterized City in past years.

Conversely, the attack relies more on individual solutions than collective rhythm, especially after the lack of harmony between midfield and the front line, all of which has caused the team to lose its usual offensive identity that made it formidable in England and Europe.

Personal Factors Casting Shadows

The human side cannot be ignored; press reports mentioned Guardiola’s recent separation from his wife, an event that may have an indirect psychological impact on his focus and professional performance, especially as football has become harsher than ever and does not forgive moments of distraction.

Future at Stake

The solution may not be an immediate departure from Manchester City, but Guardiola might need to reorganize his approach, find a balance between his philosophy and the team’s practical needs, or even seriously consider taking a break as he did in previous phases.

The most important question: Has the “Pep era at City” reached its final stage, or will the philosopher find his magical formula to return?